It is commendable that Raila Odinga has finally admitted that the Handshake and BBI have failed and Kenyans now want to engage leaders in a conversation on how to change their economic situation for better from the Bottom up. Suddenly, Raila is now busy tossing his own ideas and proposals about the economy and every else around even as he refuses to confirm he will be in the ballot in 2022. Well, we will not go into the merits of Raila’s proposals and ideas, we wish to address a more pressing concern.
Many Kenyans are concerned about where Raila is getting his ideas from and who is helping him come up with his proposals. Don’t get me wrong, it is okay for a leader to have ideas or proposals of his own just like a doctor has an idea of modes of treatments. But same way a doctor can’t prescribe a treatment for a patient before understanding what ails them, a leader should not pretend to impose his ideas and proposals from top to the bottom, without taking the time to know what are the priorities of the people and where the shoe is pinching them.
As it is now, it seems Raila may have abandoned the Handshake and the BBI Push to join Ruto in the quest for Economic Change half-heartedly as Raila appears bend on applying the BBI Model to Economics. Many BBI proposal did not sit well with Kenyans because they it did not come from Kenyans, they were by and large proposals of leaders, by leaders on how and where to change the Constitution for leaders. This is why the High Court dismissed BBI telling its proponents that Kenyans must be engaged to determine for themselves how they want to be governed.
Unfortunately, the same way nobody told BBI proponents that Kenyans wanted a bloated Parliament, nobody has told Raila what people in Rural Kenya or Manufacturers or Civil servants want for him to pretend to impose his proposals for change on them. To be sure, Raila is yet to meet representatives of people living in Rural Areas to engage them on what they feel are priorities that they want the next Government to address. Raila and ODM did not meet manufacturers before prescribing Made in Kenya and certainly, Raila is yet to meet leaders of civil servants to understand what ails civil service to propose how to fix it.
At least we have seen William Ruto engaging grassroots and elected leaders from different regions and sectors to listen to and talk about what the people want. Public participation is a basic tenet under the current Constitutional dispensation. While the leader can give his approach, like Ruto has outlined Bottom Up Economics Model as his approach, to develop specific proposals for various sectors like Raila seems to be trying to do, it behooves the leader to engage wananchi to know what they need and in what priority.
Clearly, Raila and ODM have missed the forest for the trees. While the key words of the new way of doing things are Bottom Up, Economics and Conversation, Raila and his team seem to be interested only in economics, not bottom up or having a meaningful conversation with the people. What have now is proposals coming from a few leaders at the top without any input from the many people at the Bottom, the essence is trickle down approach. Where the leader opts to talk down on the people as Raila seems to have chosen, to decree his ideas and proposals without engaging wananchi, that cannot be called a conversation.
Well, it is good start that Raila has come to appreciate that our economic model needs fixing but he owes it to Kenyans to tell them what economic model he stands for as Ruto has declared he stands for Bottom Up Model. Beyond that, Raila must engage Kenyans to hear what proposals they wish to see implemented by the next Government. The idea of 50 Leaders deciding the destiny of 50 Million Kenyans must die with BBI. Going forward, Kenyans at the Bottom to be involved in every conversation about how to improve their economic wellbeing, economic proposals of leaders, by leaders and for leaders are not welcome.